Responsibility for Bad Deeds – and for Good? The Impact of Cultural Attribution Tendencies on Cognition and Emotion
نویسندگان
چکیده
Appraisal theories of emotion assume that similar evaluations of an event result in similar emotions, whereas the evaluation itself may depend on culturally defined concepts, experiences, and values. In other words, cognitions are crucial for the elicitation and differentiation of emotions, and the impact that culture has on emotions is enclosed in their cognitive determinants. Based on this approach, our interdisciplinary project compares the cognitive elicitation of six emotions in Tonga and Germany. It tests the hypothesis that – driven by different self-concepts and corresponding attribution tendencies – members of both cultures ascribe responsibility to others and self in diverging manners. Consequently, responses should differ when it comes to emotions that hinge on these attributions. Our experimental data supports this hypothesis.
منابع مشابه
Re-Reading Mulla Sadra on the Intersection of Cognition and Emotion
Human emotions are in connection with his deeds on the one hand and his perceptions on the other, and this complicates the analysis of emotion. Furthermore, any school of thought in search of presenting a comprehensive perspective on the human should clarify its stance with regard to emotion and the position it has in the structure of human cognition and deeds. This fact places the answer to th...
متن کامل“Calling People to do Good Deeds” and “Commanding Right and Forbidding Wrong” [Amr Bil Ma'ruf and Nahi 'Anil Munkar] and its Effect on Institutionalization in the Legal System of Islamic Republic of Iran
The holy Quran has put “calling people to do good deeds” [or calling people to an act of benevolence] besides and prior to “commanding rightand forbidding wrong”, [or commanding beneficence and forbidding maleficence]. However in many interpretive and jurisprudential books, no sufficient effort has been made to elaborate the difference features between these two and their results, whose manife...
متن کاملAnger Elicitation in Tonga and Germany: The Impact of Culture on Cognitive Determinants of Emotions
The cognitive appraisal of an event is crucial for the elicitation and differentiation of emotions, and causal attributions are an integral part of this process. In an interdisciplinary project comparing Tonga and Germany, we examined how cultural differences in attribution tendencies affect emotion assessment and elicitation. Data on appraising causality and responsibility and on emotional res...
متن کاملAnger in a Just World? The Impact of Cultural Concepts on Cognition and Emotion
The cognitive appraisal of an event is crucial for the elicitation and differentiation of emotions. Similar appraisals will result in similar emotions, but the appraisal of one and the same event may depend on culturally defined concepts. Appraising an event as unjust, for instance, and its agent as responsible are cognitive determinants for anger. Justice, however, is defined through cultural ...
متن کاملThe Problem of Evil and its Attribution to God Relying on the Verses 78-79 Surah An-Nisaa
One of the fundamental issues within the theology system is evilness. This issue has been concerned by Muslim thinkers who have adopted different approaches. The intra-religious strategy is an important approach in this regard. Evilness in the Holy Quran has been focused on from different aspects. Evilness and attributing it to God is among the problems which have been pointed to in the Quran v...
متن کامل